Scapegoating the Jury: Why the Government’s “Backlog Solution” Misses the Point

Why have political leaders in this country made such a dramatic U-turn in their approach to jury trials? Is it the result of political pressure, a lack of legal understanding, or simple hypocrisy? Seren Lewis tells us the facts.

“Juries are a filter for prejudice” – David Lammy 2017

“The right to trial by jury is an important factor in the delicate balance between the power of the state and the freedom of the individual. The further it is restricted, the greater the imbalance” – Sir Keir Starmer 1992

Sir Brian Leveson published Part 1 of his Review of the Criminal Courts, in which he outlines the many challenges currently facing the criminal justice system. The report identifies numerous systemic issues and, in many respects, proposes sensible and workable solutions. These include addressing inefficiencies in case listing, disclosure practices, and workforce recruitment. The review also highlights the need for increased use of technology and remote participation, alongside stronger pre-trial case management.

However, rather than focusing on reforms that would require meaningful investment, Parliament appears to have bypassed many of these recommendations. Instead, attention has been directed toward the far more politically convenient proposal of restricting jury trials, presented to the public as a measure designed to “put victims first”. For some observers, this messaging may feel reminiscent of the promises made during the introduction of Brexit—broad political assurances that obscure the deeper structural problems facing the country.

In writing this article, I have had the benefit of observing the criminal courts from two professional perspectives: first as a court clerk and now as a pupil barrister. I have been present when defendants are informed that their trials will not take place for three years. I have witnessed families struggling with the prospect of waiting years to give evidence in historical sexual abuse trials. What I have not witnessed, however, is juries being responsible for those delays.

The reality is that court delays arise from a wide range of operational and systemic problems that occur on a daily basis.

Common causes of delay in the courts
  1. Prisoner transport issues. Defendants are brought to court by a contracted third-party company. On a typical day, many courts are delayed because defendants arrive late—or in some cases are not delivered at all. It often appears that the priority is simply ensuring the defendant arrives at some point during the day, whether that is at 10:00am or 2:00pm.
  2. Cell block failures. On occasion, cells become unusable—for example when Category A toilets become blocked and flood the holding area—making it unsafe or inhumane to detain defendants or staff within the building.
  3. Heating failures in winter. This occurs with remarkable regularity. Courtrooms can become so cold that jurors are instructed to remain in their winter coats and gloves while proceedings continue. Barristers and judges, bound by court dress, cannot easily adapt in the same way, and courts are sometimes forced to close until temporary heating is installed.
  4. Air-conditioning failures in summer. Conversely, air-conditioning systems frequently break down during warmer months. In some courtrooms the system is so loud that judges conclude proceedings cannot continue because witnesses cannot be heard. Those familiar with Court 4 at Manchester Crown Square—the so-called “super court”—will recognise this problem immediately. The witness box sits at the far end of an enormous room, making it extremely difficult for jurors to hear evidence clearly.
  5. Barrister shortages. The declining number of practitioners at the criminal bar means that trials are sometimes returned to chambers the evening before they are due to begin. As a result, both prosecution and defence teams are often forced to prepare urgently on the morning of trial, which can delay proceedings by hours or, in some cases, an entire day.
  6. Broken or incompatible technology. It is common for prosecutors to attempt to play CCTV or other digital evidence, only to discover that the court system cannot connect with counsel’s laptop or that the equipment is simply not functioning. In such circumstances, juries may be sent away while technicians attempt repairs—or, more commonly, the court must search for another available courtroom.
  7. Reduced sitting days. Government reductions in judicial sitting days have resulted in court buildings where multiple courtrooms remain unused despite the growing backlog.
  8. Limited secure docks. Custody trials require secure docks, which are not always available in every courtroom.
  9. Courtroom allocation problems. It is not unusual for both a custody trial and a bail trial to be listed in the same courtroom, each ready to begin. Only one can proceed. The other—often the bail trial—may be adjourned for years due to the lack of available court space and judicial availability.
  10. Building safety issues. Courtrooms are occasionally closed for asbestos treatment or other structural concerns.
  11. Failures in evidence playback. In rape trials, for example, an Achieving Best Evidence (ABE) interview may need to be played to the jury. Even when the jury arrives on time, technical failures—such as faulty microphones—can make the recording inaudible. A transcript may then be ordered. In buildings with more than ten courtrooms but only one working CPS printer, the jury may ultimately be sent home for the entire day while documents are printed.

This list is by no means exhaustive, but it illustrates the routine operational problems that contribute to court delays.

Open justice

Juries allow ordinary members of the public to participate directly in the justice system. This principle is fundamental to what we describe as open justice.

Removing or restricting jury trials would mean that verdicts are decided solely by legal professionals—individuals who encounter similar offences and explanations on a daily basis. It is frequently argued that legal professionals become “case-hardened”, and there is some truth in that observation. Criminal solicitors, barristers and judges are routinely exposed to the most serious and disturbing allegations. Over time, professionals inevitably learn to compartmentalise.

This is precisely where juries play an essential role.

Jurors approach cases without prior exposure to the facts, without familiarity with the individuals involved, and without professional desensitisation to the nature of the allegations. They bring a diverse, community-based perspective to the justice system.

They also hear only the evidence that is legally admissible. Jurors are not present for bad-character applications that are refused, nor for section 41 applications that are not permitted. Their decision-making therefore rests entirely on the evidence presented in court.

Deliberation among twelve individuals further reduces the risk that a single person’s bias or preconception will dominate the outcome.

For these reasons, juries remain integral to a defendant’s right to a fair trial.

“‘The proposal to strip jury trials from offences carrying up to three years imprisonment is not administrative reform. It is a constitutional surrender. It says that when the state seeks to take a person’s liberty, the voice of the public is optional’ – Rob Rinder 2026”

Limiting jury trials will not reduce the backlog

Most delays occur before a trial even begins.

The largest sources of delay in the criminal justice system arise well before a case reaches trial. These include:

  • Evidence disclosure issues
  • Police investigation time
  • Digital evidence analysis
  • Waiting for barristers to become available
  • Delays in expert reports
  • Administrative backlogs

Even in a judge-only trial, the court would still need to wait for prosecution evidence to be prepared, for the defence to complete case preparation, and for disclosure obligations to be satisfied.

Jury trials represent only a small proportion of cases

Most criminal cases in England and Wales are not decided by juries at all. Approximately 90% of cases are dealt with in the Magistrates’ Court. Even within the Crown Court, many defendants plead guilty. Removing juries would therefore affect only a relatively small proportion of cases.

Jury selection in the UK is extremely quick

Contrary to the portrayal often seen in American courtroom dramas, jury selection in England and Wales is a straightforward administrative process. It typically takes less than 30 minutes, and jurors are rarely questioned individually.

Once selected, jurors remain within the court building and are generally ready when called. It is exceptionally rare for court proceedings to be delayed because of jurors, unless there are external disruptions such as transport strikes or travel incidents.

Trials would not necessarily become shorter

Even in a judge-only system, trials would still require witnesses to give evidence, to be cross-examined, and for legal arguments to be made.

Some commentators argue that removing juries would eliminate the need for lengthy judicial summings-up. This assumption is incorrect. A judge sitting alone would still need to review the evidence carefully before reaching a verdict and ensure that the relevant legal principles have been properly considered.

While this alternative process might shorten a trial marginally—perhaps by twenty minutes—it would not significantly reduce the current backlog of approximately 82,000 cases.

Furthermore, when juries retire to deliberate, the trial judge typically uses that time to deal with other matters listed before the court. If a jury deliberates for three days, the judge may complete three days’ worth of additional work. In a judge-only system, that time would instead be spent considering the verdict, meaning other court work would be postponed—potentially increasing the backlog rather than reducing it.

Appeals would likely increase

If juries were removed, it is highly probable that the number of appeals would increase.

Juries do not provide detailed reasons for their verdicts. By contrast, a judge sitting alone would be required to give a fully reasoned judgement explaining how the law was applied to the evidence. Such judgments would inevitably become the subject of detailed scrutiny and challenge on appeal.

As a result, defendants would have greater scope to contest verdicts, potentially increasing the workload of the appellate courts.

The conclusion

The growing backlog in the criminal courts is real, serious and deeply damaging for victims, defendants and the wider justice system. But removing juries will not fix it.

The causes of delay are structural: failing court buildings, broken technology, shortages at the criminal bar, reduced sitting days, transport failures, and chronic underinvestment across the entire justice system. These are the issues identified in Sir Brian Leveson’s review. They are also the issues experienced daily by those working inside the courts. None of them are caused by juries.

Restricting jury trials is therefore not a solution to the backlog. It is a political shortcut.

More importantly, it risks weakening one of the most fundamental protections in a democratic legal system. Jury trials ensure that when the state seeks to remove an individual’s liberty, that decision is not made solely by the state itself but by ordinary members of the public. They bring independence, community perspective and collective deliberation to the administration of justice.

Seren LewisRemoving that safeguard in the name of efficiency would represent a profound constitutional shift. It would not meaningfully reduce delays, but it would diminish public participation in the justice system and concentrate greater power in the hands of the state.

If the government is serious about addressing the crisis in the courts, it must confront the real causes: investment, infrastructure, staffing and proper case management. Until those issues are addressed, the backlog will remain.

Juries are not the problem. And sacrificing them will not be the solution.

Seren Lewis is currently completing her first six pupillage under the supervision of Mark Pritchard and will be available to instruct from August 2026. To instruct Seren on an upcoming case, please contact her clerks.

Menu