Samuel Eskdale, representing a Defendant charged with committing an act outraging public decency, makes a successful application to dismiss the charge.
Following submissions highlighting required elements of the offence, namely that the “two person rule” was not satisfied, the Judge at Liverpool Crown Court acceded to the application.
Samuel was instructed by Tim Hughes of Cuttle and Co Solicitors.
Samuel addresses the relevant features of the offence and application below. This article is for general information only and is not intended to constitute legal advice.
Outraging Public Decency
For an offence of committing an act of outraging public decency, the Prosecution must prove that The Crown is required to prove that the Defendant:
- did an act that was lewd, obscene or disgusting, and
- there are two or more persons present who are capable of seeing the nature of the act, even if they did not actually see it.
Lewd, obscene or disgusting
Limb A of the test is usually determined by reference to the definition of a lewd, obscene or disgusting act derived from Shaw v DPP [1962] AC220 at 281. A jury will be asked to determine whether, as a matter of fact, the act in question was lewd, obscene or disgusting by recognised standards of public decency.
The Public Element
Limb B of the test is referred to by the Court of Appeal in R v Hamilton [2007] EWCA Crim 2062 as “the public element” and requires the Prosecution to establish that there were at least two people both present and capable of seeing the nature of the act, even where they did not actually see it.
If, like in the present case, there are considerable evidential difficulties for the Prosecution to establish that one or both of the individuals were both present and capable of seeing the nature of the act, it may not be an offence made out in law.
Challenge to the veracity of the Prosecution’s evidence, and the environmental factors that might be considered by any jury when asked whether an individual is capable of seeing an act will be key to any application to dismiss. Like in the present case, an individual’s distance from the Defendant, their physical position in any area near to the Defendant, any obstructions to their view and any other relevant environmental factors may be determinative.
In the case of Hamilton [2007], it was established that the question of whether an individual was capable of seeing the nature of an act would ordinarily be left to a jury to determine as a matter of fact. However, a key feature of whether such a question can be left to a jury, will be the existence or not of any supporting evidence from that individual, such as identification of them, evidence from them as to their involvement and any other supporting evidence to establish their capability of viewing the act.
The simple assertion by the Prosecution that the individual was present, so they were capable, is not enough.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.
