Not guilty on both counts after five day jury trial at Chester Crown Court

Benjamin Knight of Central Chambers has secured unanimous not guilty verdicts for D at Chester Crown Court following a five day jury trial. Benjamin Knight - Secures acquittal in GBH trial.

D (17 years old at the time) faced counts of causing Grievous Bodily Harm with Intent and of Possession of A Bladed Article (knife) arising from an incident in the early hours, about four years ago, in which a man suffered serious stab wounds to the abdomen. The Crown said D was the aggressor.

The jury came to see a different picture. A group of men in their 20s were damaging property and throwing street furniture about, disturbing residents who were asleep. Their actions included throwing a signpost through the window of a parked car belonging to D’s girlfriend’s flatmate.

D threw on some clothes and went down to challenge what they were doing. For his trouble he was beaten and kicked by the group. As he tried to get up, he swung round a piece of metal from the road. That caused the injury to the complainant, as D accepted. His case was that he was acting in self-defence in the moment and feared that he would be seriously injured if he did not get away from the group of men.

The defence put the investigation under close scrutiny. The officer in charge had to accept that several important lines of enquiry were never followed and that there was no proper justification for that. No signed statement was ever obtained from a local resident who spoke to officers at the scene.

The jury returned unanimous not guilty verdicts on both counts on the fifth day. D is pleased to be able, at last, to move on with his life.

Benjamin Knight was instructed by Alex Nash of Morton’s Solicitors.

Central Chambers crime team acts in serious and complex criminal cases across England and Wales.

Menu