Delving into DAPOs – Chris Wallace explores the incoming pilot scheme.

What is a Domestic Abuse Protection Order?

Author’s Note: Although the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 uses more neutral language[1] to set out the person who should be the subject of the order and the person the order is made to protect, for readability this article will refer to “perpetrator” and “victim” respectively for clarity.

photograph of a distressed woman with tape on her mouth, displaying the words "speak"

The Domestic Abuse Protection Order (or “DAPO” for short) is a new type of protective order introduced in the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 (“the DA Act”). The intention of parliament was to create a new regime and umbrella of security for victims of domestic abuse. This article focuses on the use of DAPOs in the family court arena, however these orders are not restricted to civil matters; and police-led domestic abuse protective orders can be applied for within the criminal jurisdiction as standalone or ancillary orders to go hand-in-hand with the Domestic Abuse Protection Notices introduced this year.

The current regime of occupation and non-molestation orders[2] provides a degree of protection for victims of domestic abuse. However, during parliamentary discussion on the Domestic Abuse Bill and subsequent Act, it became clear the importance of victims being able to access a protective order with more powers, which provided a degree of flexibility to the court. Furthermore, the DAPO as proposed would provide for a way for third parties to apply for a protective order on behalf of a victim.

The DAPO pilot scheme is due to be trialled in Greater Manchester from November 2024, alongside Gwent, and the London boroughs of Croydon, Bromley, and Sutton.

Applying for a DAPO

In a change to the non-molestation order regime, an application for a DAPO can be made either the victim in the usual way, or by a third-party provided they have permission from the court to do so.[3]

Similar to the associated persons test[4] for a non-molestation order, the victim and perpetrator must be personally connected.[5] For example:

  1. married;
  2. civil partners;
  3. engaged or in a civil partnership agreement;
  4. are in an intimate personal relationship, or have been previously;
  5. are parents of or have parental responsibility for the same child;
  6. relatives (as defined in s63(1) Family Law Act 1996);

The main difference being that for parties who did not cohabit, it is no longer necessary to demonstrate a relationship of “significant duration” which may come as a relief to victims who find themselves hounded by determined off/on or casual partners that turn abusive.[6]

Unlike a non-molestation order, the victim must be over 16 (with the usual requirement to be represented by a litigation friend if the victim is under 18), and a DAPO can only be made against a person aged 18 or over. Whilst the pilot scheme is active, for a DAPO to be considered and enforced, the perpetrator must live in the area in which the police are running the pilot — within Greater Manchester for example — but the victim can live outside of the pilot area.

An interim DAPO can be made without notice if it is “just and convenient”[7] to do so in similar circumstances to a non-molestation order; with consideration of whether lack of an immediate order would cause significant harm to the victim, cause the victim to be put off or stopped from making the application, or the perpetrator is deliberately evading service of notice to frustrate matters. Again, like a non-molestation order, the court must list a return hearing on-notice as soon as it is just and convenient to do so.

The addition of scope for a third party to make a DAPO application facilitates social workers and medical staff making applications on behalf of a client or patient whom they need to protect. It also permits charities and domestic abuse agencies to make applications on behalf of those who access their services. The order leaves the door open as to who may be allowed to make such an application including concerned family members who may wish to intervene in situations that become problematic, however the extent to which the court will entertain such third-party applications is yet to be tested in practice.

Lastly, the High Court and family court of course can make a DAPO of its own initiative[8] if the victim and perpetrator are parties in family proceedings.

Operation

Once the court makes a DAPO, under s. 35 of the DA Act the court can impose any requirements that the court considers necessary to protect the victim.

Like a non-molestation order, the DAPO can prohibit a perpetrator from:

  1. contacting a victim;
  2. staying a specified distance away from a home or other premises;
  3. evicting a victim from premises;
  4. entering specified premises.

However it is very important to note that this is not an exhaustive list and any prohibition or restriction can be made by the court; so long as it does not conflict with that person’s religious beliefs, interfere with their work or education as far as possible, or conflict with any court order or injunction that may be applicable. If there is a conflict, the court can still impose a requirement if it is simply impractical to avoid it.

A DAPO, however, has much larger and sharper teeth than a non-molestation order. The order has no minimum or maximum duration, and the court’s powers are much wider in scope. For example, for the first time in a civil order, a DAPO permits the court to impose an electronic monitoring (aka tagging) requirement for up to 12 months. It allows the court to impose a positive requirement such as a rehabilitation activity like a domestic abuse perpetrator’s programme; and s. 41 of the Act introduces a compulsory notification requirement for the duration of the order mirroring the requirements imposed on those found guilty of sexual offences.

The flexibility of the order means that courts can stagger the duration of the imposed conditions, for example a perpetrator can be restricted from coming with a set distance of the victim’s property for a period of 12 months, but be GPS tagged for just six.

It all comes down to what measures the court decides are necessary and proportionate to protect the victim from either domestic abuse, or the risks presented by the perpetrator. Most importantly, a DAPO is a civil order and does not require a conviction for the court to make one.

Breach of the order or of the notification requirements invokes an automatic power of arrest, and penalties for breach of the order without reasonable excuse can be severe, resulting in maximum sentence of five years’ imprisonment for the either-way offence if convicted on indictment.

Information

for the public

For victims — suffering domestic abuse is miserable and scary, and escape can feel like a distant goal. Applying for a DAPO can take you one step closer to that goal, and the process shouldn’t be intimidating. For people with limited finances, legal aid can help cover the costs of making an application, and most solicitors who deal with family law should be willing to help.

Failing that, local and national domestic abuse charities such as End the Fear (www.endthefear.co.uk) the National Centre for Domestic Violence (www.ncdv.org.uk) and Cheshire Without Abuse (www.mycwa.org.uk) to name but a few have excellent resources and provide valuable services to those who need them.

On the other hand, being served with a DAPO could seem like a confusing nightmare particularly if it came out of the blue. Again, legal aid may be available in certain circumstances, but for those on the receiving end the options are slightly more limited. Speak to a solicitor in the first instance to see what your options are. In this early stage of the pilot scheme, it’s important to check the rules and procedures have been followed correctly by both the courts and the other side.

for professionals

For any professional working with victims of domestic abuse, be it social workers, NHS workers or charity staff, knowing what to do when applying for a DAPO is vital.

First of all, if you suspect a client or patient as being at risk of immediate harm from domestic abuse, follow any safeguarding procedures that may be in place and/or contact the police if you feel that immediate intervention is warranted. A DAPO is a longer-term solution, but applications take time.

If you have been authorised to or have made the decision to apply for a DAPO, collate as much evidence as you can regarding the situation. Speak to the victim and obtain their views on whether they support an application for a DAPO; even if they do not wish to pursue it themselves.

Complete form DA1 and write a witness statement. Set out your concerns clearly, chronologically if possible, and with as much relevant detail as you can in a witness statement. Reference contemporaneous evidence or incidents if available.

Make sure you add paragraphs that clearly explain why the application is being made by yourselves or your agency instead of by the victim directly, how long you have been working with the victim, and whether their contact details should be kept from the perpetrator. This should be done using form DA2.

Importantly, if applicable, speak to your legal department or seek external legal advice.

for Practitioners

The new pilot is managed by r. 36ZG of the Family Procedure Rules[9] to be introduced imminently.

Direct applications for DAPOs are made using the DA1 form, and third-party permission applications are made using DA2; both of which should be available for download from the gov.uk website imminently and will be similar to the existing FL401. Applications will need to be accompanied by a witness statement; and any application also needs to set out:

  1. the contact details for the victim;
  2. the opinion of the victim (if the application is by a third-party);
  3. property details such as occupants and mortgagees/landlords (if applicable);
  4. the dates and times that the perpetrator normally works, attends education, or would attend places of worship;
  5. any other court orders or injunctions the perpetrator is or was subject to; and
  6. any previous applications in respect of the perpetrator (including a DAPO) which has been refused by the court.

Ex parte/without notice applications must state why they are not being made on notice in the body of the witness statement.

Third party applications for permission have additional requirements. Accompanying the DA1, the DA2 form needs to set out:

  1. whether the victim’s contact details should be kept confidential;
  2. the reasons for making the application in lieu of the victim; and
  3. the connection between the victim and the third party.

Practitioners can make an oral application during the course of family proceedings without notice, but be prepared to set out all of the above information for the court and explain to the judge why notice has not been given in advance.

Legal aid is available for both victims and perpetrators under the means and merit test, with exemptions for merit as per non-molestation orders. And whilst court fees for applications are covered by the Government during the pilot scheme, at the time of writing there is no further information on the costs of applications in the future.

Importantly, positive requirements for a DAPO require evidence about the suitability and enforceability of the same from the person responsible for supervising compliance with the requirement. That evidence can either be in written form, or orally in court. If a DAPO is made without this evidence, the court can be asked to make an interim DAPO excluding the positive requirement until the evidence can be sourced to make a determination.

It goes without saying that monitoring requirements cannot be imposed at ex parte/without notice hearings, and practitioners should expect strong Article 6 and 8 ECHR arguments given the draconian nature of the restrictions.

Additionally, the March 2024 Guidance on DAPNs and DAPOs[10] is a valuable resource for those on the front line of domestic abuse injunctions.

What next?

What does this mean for the future of protective orders in domestic abuse settings? Of course, greater protection for those at risk of, or suffering from domestic abuse ought to be heralded and welcomed by professionals and the public alike, and rightly so, but at what cost? The new orders have the potential to be significantly more intrusive on one’s rights than previous civil injunctions, imposing restrictions on an individual hitherto reserved for the criminal jurisdiction.

Currently, it is not out of the ordinary for respondents to a non-molestation order to accede to the terms of the order rather than the court make findings against them, particularly if the applicant has legal representation and the respondent is a litigant in person. The phrase “if you’re not going to go near them, what’s the harm of agreeing to the order?” springs to mind; and not opposing a non-molestation order has no significant impact if there is no risk of breach. Thankfully, on this front a number of non-molestation orders are made by the courts to then expire without further issue.

Compared to non-molestation orders, DAPOs are a different beast. With the threat of electronic monitoring and notification requirements; alongside positive obligations and a (yet) untested free reign for courts to impose whatever restrictive conditions they deem necessary; the potential for imbalance and disproportionate infringement of a person’s ECHR rights is significant. As is the potential for misuse.

So, what about the burden and standard of proof? Unlike the criminal courts, the family courts operate on the civil standard of proof. For example, in criminal law, for an individual’s freedom to be curtailed, the bar is set rather high — as the words habeas corpus dangle on the lips of every criminal law lecturer — with the arbiter of fact having to be sure that the individual has committed the offence before they can receive their comeuppance. In short, placing someone on an electronic curfew or restriction for criminal activity requires the court to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt.

Not so for civil injunctions. Considering the possibility for a respondent to a DAPO being both GPS tagged, and being compelled to hand over both their identification and biometric information to the police; is it lawful that the much lower civil standard of proof used in DAPO cases?

The curious, and perhaps unfortunate answer is yes. The 2023 case of Jones v Birmingham City Council[11] considered this very issue. Putting to bed the decision in McCann[12] which called for a higher standard of proof for civil anti-social behaviour orders (ASBOs) the Supreme Court confirmed that the standard of proof for civil cases (including those considering behaviour of a criminal nature) is the tried and tested “balance of probabilities”.

But is it still appropriate in DAPO cases? That question begs to be tested during the course of the pilot scheme; and no doubt the extent at which courts can impose quasi-criminal sanctions in civil injunctions will be thoroughly challenged. The burden of proof however rests firmly with the applicant, and arguably a well presented and robust evidential case ought to be imperative before any judge considers imposing draconian restrictions on an individual.

For better or for worse.


The Author

Chris Wallace is ready to accept instruction on public and private children law matters for parents, children, and local authorities alike; Court of Protection and Deprivation of Liberty issues; and preliminary financial dispute hearings. Chris excels in dealing with clients who are vulnerable and can advise clients with a wide degree of difficulties both effectively and directly; specialising in representing neurodiverse and disabled clients from an array of backgrounds.

He is available for instruction via his clerks who may be contacted via email or telephone.


References

[1] Domestic Abuse Act 2021, s. 27 (DAA 2021)

[2] Family Law Act 1996, s. 42 (FLA 1996)

[3] DAA 2021, s. 28(1)

[4] FLA 1996, s. 42(2)

[5] DAA 2021, s. 2

[6]My one night stand stalked me for 13 years, MyLondon News Online, 10/02/2022,  https://www.mylondon.news/news/health/my-one-night-stand-stalked-22991766 [accessed 28/09/2024]

[7] DAA 2021, s. 34(1)

[8] Ibid. s. 31(2)

[9] Practice Direction Update No. 4 of 2024, McFarlane J, Online: https://www.justice.gov.uk/documents/7815.pdf

[10] Domestic Abuse Protection Notices and Domestic Abuse Protection Orders (DAPNs and DAPOs), Ministry of Justice, March 2024, https://www.lccsa.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Guidance-for-legal-practitioners-on-DAPO-pilot-March-2024.pdf [online] accessed 27/09/2024

[11] Jones v Birmingham City Council and the Secretary of State for the Home Department [2023] UKSC 27

[12] R (McCann) v Crown Court at Manchester [2003] 1 AC 787

Menu