The Inquests Into The Death of Ben Leonard: February 2020 (adjourned), November 2022 (adjourned) & January/February 2024 (final)

Benjamin David Leonard was born on 1st November 2001 and died of head injuries on 26th August 2018, sustained from a fall from the Great Orme in Llandudno, North Wales. Ben died shortly after falling. At the time of his death, he had recently completed his GCSEs and planned to attend college to pursue his ambition of becoming a scriptwriter. Ben had been on a trip with the Reddish Explorer Scout Association at the time of the fall from the Great Orme.

Inquest of Benjamin Leonard - Negligence and Scout Association
Benjamin David Leonard
1st November 2001 – 26th August 2018

In autumn, 2019, Nick McCall was approached by mutual family friends to meet with Jackie and Dave Leonard (Ben’s parents). They were to discuss the forthcoming inquest into their son’s death. The inquest was listed for five days in February 2020.  Legal Aid is difficult to obtain in such situations, so Nick agreed to see if he could help the bereaved parents take on the Scout Association, on a pro bono basis. 

Jackie and Dave had not been provided with any information from the Scout Association as to the circumstances and events surrounding Ben’s death. They, along with Tom Leonard (Ben’s big brother), wanted to know what had happened to Ben. 

Evidence was later to be adduced that the Scout Association had recorded in meetings that they hoped that the family would not be represented at the inquest. Evidence was also later adduced, that the Scout Association’s lawyers had described Nick as a mere “do-gooder family lawyer”, in their attendance notes.

Inquest 1 – February 2020

Nick acted alone on behalf of Ben’s family at a week-long jury inquest against representatives of the Scout Association. The Scout Association’s paid legal team included senior Queen’s Counsel (as was). Lawyers for the Scout Association attempted to represent all Scouts Properly Interested Persons under one legal umbrella, despite invitations by the coroner to recognise potential conflicts of interest. The inquest was adjourned on day five, after four days of evidence, after it was found that a witness from the Scout Association had misled the jury.  At the conclusion, the coroner also made a 20 point, “prevention of future death report”, pursuant to Regulation 28, which included:

(1) the arranging of the trip did not adhere to the Scout Association’s own safety policies;

(2) such policies were not adequately understood at grass roots level;

(3) safety policies exist but are not implemented;

(4) there was no written risk assessment;

(5) there was no dynamic risk assessment;

(6) there is not a full understanding of what a risk assessment is;

(7) there is not a full understanding of when to do written, oral and dynamic risk assessments;

(8) there had been no approval sought for the trip, as required from the District Commissioner;

(9) there was an absence of a permanent District Commissioner to give oversight to the leadership of the group;

(10) there was no meaningful discussion between the Scout leaders as to the plan for the trip on the Orme;

(11) the leaders did not have a participant list, nor list of phone numbers, for the boys;

(12) there was no route planned for the Orme trip;

(13) no instruction or briefing was given to the boys;

(14) each of the three leaders assumed the three boys were with one of the leaders, when in fact they were not, they were on their own;

(15) there was no effective leadership for the group;

(16) the Scout Association failed to provide the court with full information about the action it had in fact taken concerning its leaders on the trip post death;

(17) the Scout Association created a misleading impression in the evidence concerning its actions regarding its leaders on the trip post-death;

(18) the Scout Association is distant from its membership through its federated branches of 8,000 charities and layers of hierarchy, meaning that it cannot know how health and safety is executed at ground level;

(19) the health and safety and training intervals for leaders are said to be every three years, with no way of assessing their competencies; and finally,

(20) the lives of young people are being put at risk by the Scout Association’s failure to recognise the inadequacies of its operational practice and the part this has played in the death of Ben

Inquest 2 – November 2022

During the intervening period before Inquest 2, the Leonard family instructed solicitors, Fieldfisher to act on their behalf. Fieldfisher instructed Nick to continue to represent the family.  Nick’s pro-bono status came to an end at this point.

By this stage, the Properly Interested Persons in respect of the Scout witnesses had each become separately represented by their own respective solicitors and silks.  Bernard Richmond KC, at Nick’s request, became Nick’s leader.  Bernard had been an invaluable source of support and mentoring to Nick during Inquest 1.

Between inquests 1 and 2, Fieldfisher had instigated a wholesale disclosure exercise which had resulted in 60,000 documents being obtained.

On the second day of the November 2022 inquest, the matter was adjourned again, due to the Scout Association’s failure to provide full disclosure.

Inquest 3 – January and February 2024 (8 weeks inquest)

Bernard Richmond KC led Nick throughout the inquest, who both worked alongside the Fieldfisher team of solicitors; Jill Greenfield, Harvinder Kaur and Harriet Salvesen-Sawh. The legal team for the family worked hard until the full circumstances of failings by the Scouts Association emerged.

The focus of the Leonard’s legal team, led by Bernard, included the planning of the trip, its authorisation, the adequacy of the training of the volunteers, absent risk assessments, the governance of the Scout Association, its policies and procedures, the lack of any external oversight to ensure safety compliance, and the nature of the corporate response and actions following Ben’s death.

In the eighth week of the inquest, the jury returned a unanimous conclusion of Unlawful Killing by the Scout Leader and Assistant Scout Leader, contributed to by Neglect of the Scout Association.

The Scout Association was also referred to the police by the coroner for investigation of Conspiracy to Pervert the Course of Justice.

A further and lengthy Prevention of Future Death Report was also written by the coroner, alongside letters to the relevant Secretaries of State, in order to convey a request by the Leonard family, that a Public Inquiry be undertaken into the Scout Association and its approach to the safety of children. This Report be found in full here:

Final PFD Benjamin David Leonard Inquest 22.02.2024.pdf

The Report is scathing of the “institutionally defensive” Scout Association and the matter has since been referred to the police.

Jackie, Dave and Tom Leonard were accompanied at the inquest by their family and friends, including the mothers of two other boys who had died as a result of falls during scouting activities.

Central Chambers offers its deepest condolences to Jackie, Dave and Tom Leonard, and their extended family and friends for the loss of Ben. They have each remained quietly determined and have acted with the utmost dignity throughout the five-and-a-half years it has taken to reach this inquest conclusion.

The future

The case may have far-reaching implications and it is hoped that lessons are learned and that adequate safety systems and monitoring can be established in order to ensure that the failures which led to Ben’s death will not be repeated.

In the tragic case of Ben Leonard’s death, the journey through multiple inquests underscores the vital importance of families being represented during these proceedings. Without legal representation, families may face significant challenges in uncovering the truth and achieving justice for their loved ones. Ben’s family’s experience demonstrates how having dedicated legal support can make a profound difference in the outcome of an inquest. From the initial pro bono representation by Nick McCall to the involvement of Fieldfisher solicitors and Bernard Richmond KC, the Leonard family’s perseverance led to crucial revelations and accountability.

This case highlights the necessity of ensuring that families have access to legal aid for inquests (which is currently not easily obtainable), as it can be a fundamental factor in achieving transparency, accountability, and ultimately, closure for grieving families.

Please see the link below, for those seeking legal aid in inquests:

Legal aid: apply for exceptional case funding – GOV.UK (www.gov.uk)

Menu