Tony Williams, instructed by the Crown Prosecution Service, successfully prosecutes Defendant for coercive and controlling behaviour towards particularly vulnerable complainant during unusually long and complicated trial.
The Defendant and the Complainant in this case had been in a relationship for just over a year, having moved in together within a matter of weeks. During their relationship, the Complainant was subjected to a litany of coercive and controlling behaviours at the hands of the Defendant, including:

- using physical violence against her on multiple occasions, including throwing a coke can at her stomach whilst pregnant with his child;
- threatening violence against the Complainant’s family;
- accessing and monitoring her mobile telephone and social media accounts, and sending messages to others via her accounts purporting to be her;
- installing cameras in their home to monitor her movements;
- repeatedly making unfounded accusations of “cheating” on him;
- threatening to make false reports to social services to have her children taken from her;
- “winding up” the Complainant before recording her reactions on his mobile phone in an attempt to portray himself as the victim.
The Complainant suffered from a number of health issues, including a severe speech impediment which rendered her effectively non-verbal. In light of her difficulties expressing herself, she initially wrote an 18-page letter for the police to describe the domestic abuse she had suffered. It was quickly established that it would be extremely difficult, if not impossible, for her to give live evidence at trial.
Following thorough advice from Tony, and with the assistance of an intermediary utilising a range of communication tools, the Complainant was able to give her evidence over three days of pre-recorded “Achieving Best Evidence” police interviews and two days of pre-recorded questioning under s28 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999. The Complainant’s daughter, a teenager, also gave pre-recorded evidence of the domestic abuse she had seen during her mother’s relationship with the Defendant.
During a trial lasting nine days – an unusually lengthy trial for offences of domestic abuse – the jury viewed the pre-recorded evidence of the Complainant and her daughter, heard live evidence from friends and family of the complainant, heard live evidence from their social worker and the officer in the case, and watched videos recorded by the Complainant’s daughter and the Defendant himself. They ultimately found him guilty of coercive and controlling behaviour and assault occasioning actual bodily harm.
The Defendant was sentenced on 1st October 2024. HHJ Landale invited submissions regarding extended sentences for dangerous offenders in light of the thoroughly manipulative behaviour of which the Defendant was convicted, together with his previous criminal record.
A sentence of 4 years 6 months’ custody was imposed for coercive and controlling behaviour. For the assault occasioning actual bodily harm, he received a concurrent sentence of 4 years’ custody with an added 1 year extension period in light of the Judge’s finding of dangerousness. As a consequence of the extension period, having been found dangerous, he will serve 2/3rds of that custodial sentence as opposed to the usual half. He will also be subject to an extended licence period upon being released. In addition, the Court imposed an indefinite Restraining Order to protect the Complainant against the risks of further contact from him.
Tony enjoys a busy criminal practice in which he prosecutes and defends across the Northern Circuit and beyond, with substantial experience of dealing with vulnerable witnesses and clients. His profile can be found here. To instruct Tony, please get in touch with our clerking team.
